FCA Confirms Obviousness of Lilly’s Tadalafil Patent
In Eli Lilly Canada Inc. v. Mylan Pharmaceuticals ULC, 2020 FC 816, Justice St-Louis held that the asserted claims of Lilly’s Patent... Read More
Suffice it to Say, Pending Claims Are Irrelevant for Sufficiency
The Federal Court of Appeal clarified in Pharmascience v. Bristol-Myers Squibb, 2022 FCA 142, that the specification of the issued patent, not... Read More
Birds of a Feather Will Not Flock Together: Section 6.02 of PM(NOC) Regulations Prohibits Trials of Common Issues Absent Consent
The Federal Court of Appeal set aside a Federal Court order requiring a trial of common issues from two separate actions initiated... Read More
Degree of Care is a Relevant Consideration in Assessing Javelo Likelihood of Confusion
On April 20, 2020, the Federal Court of Appeal dismissed Clorox’s appeal from a decision of Justice Grammond of the Federal Court... Read More
Opting Out: Copyright Board Tariffs are not Mandatory
The Federal Court of Appeal’s decision in York University v. The Canadian Copyright Licensing Agency (Access Copyright) is a lengthy judgment with important... Read More
Court of Appeal dismisses Pfizer’s motion to strike PM(NOC) action as abusive
The Court of Appeal recently determined that the institution of proceedings under the “new” PM(NOC) Regulations, is not re-litigation or an abuse... Read More
Not A Wet Eye In The Court: TearLab Appeal Dismissed
In TearLab v I-MED, the Federal Court of Appeal dismissed TearLab’s appeal of Justice Manson’s dismissal of its motion for an interlocutory... Read More
Trial Judges Entitled To Some “Leeway” On Construction
On September 6, 2016, the Court of Appeal dismissed Nova Chemicals Corporations appeal from a judgment finding its SURPASS product infringes Canadian... Read More
LINGAYEN Trade-mark Cannot Be Preserved – Court of Appeal Clarifies Test for Marks Descriptive of Place of Origin
MC Imports Inc. appealed a decision of the Federal Court that invalidated its trade-mark for LINGAYEN in association with Filipino food products... Read More
Failure to Disclose Public Servant Status Will Not Void a Patent
On February 5, 2016 Justice Boivin (writing on behalf of the Court of Appeal) released the reasons for judgment in Brown v.... Read More
Federal Court of Appeal upholds prohibition application dismissal under s. 6(5)(b) of the NOC Regulations
Bayer Inc. et al., v. Fresenius Kabi Canada Ltd., 2016 FCA 13 Bayer appealed the dismissal of its application for a prohibition... Read More
A Perk for PERKOPOLIS: Limits of Non-Statutory Trademark Invalidity
In Concierge Connection Inc v. Venngo Inc, 2015 FCA 215, the Federal Court of Appeal allowed Concierge’s appeal, with reasons delivered from... Read More