University Professor Unable to Rely on Copyright Fair Use in Plagiarism Suspension
On July 15, 2015, Justice Bich of the Quebec Court of Appeal released her judgment in Syndicat des professeures et professeurs de... Read More
Pot-shots from the sidelines not enough to disprove inherent anticipation
On June 15, 2015, Justice Barnes released his public Judgment and Reasons in a prohibition application involving Mylan and Canadian Patent No.... Read More
No one is higher than the law – Headshop trade-mark infringer jailed for contempt
Hightimes Smoke Shop and Gifts, a headshop located in Niagara Falls, was previously ordered to pay $55,000 in damages and costs relating... Read More
Inherent Distinctiveness Must Consider Potential Uses Of Marks, Not Merely Their Actual Uses
Constellation Brands Inc. and related companies appealed a decision of the Trade-Marks Opposition Board that rejected Constellation’s opposition under s. 38 of... Read More
A Sheep In Wolf’s Clothing – Alleged Errors of Fact Should Not Be Dressed Up As Errors Of Law
The Federal Court of Appeal recently considered two competing appeals regarding patents listed on the Patent Register against Alcon’s moxifloxacin product, VIGAMOX.... Read More
Court of Appeal Is Not The Place to Reargue Factual Findings
On September 16, 2015, the Federal Court of Appeal dismissed Actavis’s appeal from a judgment of the Federal Court prohibiting the Minister... Read More
Cleaning Up the Waste: Federal Court Invalidates Patent for Treating Waste Material from Mining Operations
On August 24, 2015, Justice Phelan held that Canadian Patent No. 2,515,581 is invalid for obviousness (2015 FC 997). This action involved... Read More
Absent Special Circumstances, Interlocutory Trademark Decision Not Subject To Judicial Review
McDowell applied for judicial review of an interlocutory decision of the Trade-Marks Opposition Board that had refused to grant McDowell leave to... Read More
Can’t have your steak and eat it too – expunging TM’s for deviated use
Justice Kane dismissed an appeal from the Registrar of Trade-Marks expunging Padcon’s trade-mark for “THE OUTRIGGER STEAKHOUSE AND BAR” pursuant to section... Read More
Patent listing under 4(2)(b) – perfect match not required
In Eli Lilly Canada Inc v Attorney General of Canada, 2015 FCA 166, Justice Nadon allowed an appeal from Justice Bédard affirming... Read More
Competition Bureau Launches Public Consultation on IP Enforcement Guidelines
The Competition Bureau has released draft and updated Intellectual Property Enforcement Guidelines for public consultation, and is seeking comments and feedback by... Read More
Sound Prediction: Self-evident Elements Need Not Be Explicitly Disclosed
On June 3, 2015, the Federal Court of Appeal held that elements that would be self-evident to the skilled person need not... Read More
Supreme Court dismisses ramipril section 8 damages appeal
On April 20, 2015, the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed from the bench Pfizer’s appeal arising from Apotex Ramipril FCA. The Supreme Court took... Read More
“URBAN PLANET” and “PLANET”: A trade-mark dispute that was out of this world
On December 19, 2014, Justice Boswell of the Federal Court released the judgment and reasons in Jacques Vert Group Limited (“JVG”) v.... Read More
An Invitation to Attend (From the land of 10,000 lakes)
On January 7, 2015, Justice Stewart of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, released her endorsement in Arctic Cat Inc. et al.... Read More
Tobacco packaging trade-mark goes up in smoke
On December 18, 2014, Justice Bédard of the Federal Court, released her judgment and reasons in Philip Morris Products S.A. v. Imperial... Read More
Seeking to Intervene? Proceed Quickly with Unique and Valuable Insights or Else
On February 2, 2015, Justice Stratas released his reasons for dismissing Canada’s Research Based Pharmaceutical Companies (“Rx&D”) motion for leave to intervene... Read More
That is Going to Cost You: Willful Infringement of Trade-mark and failure to participate in Court proceeding results in cost sanctions
On October 24, 2014, Justice Noël of the Federal Court, released the Reasons for Judgment on a motion for default judgment in... Read More
Threatening sanctions without a legal basis
The Denturist Association of Canada’s (“DAC”) five digit procedure codes are licensed to its provincial associations (including the Denturist Association of Ontario... Read More
Overrun by nettles: Government to prune the PM(NOC) Regulations
Industry Canada has announced its intention to amend the Patented Medicines (Notice of Compliance) Regulations. These proposed changes focus on the issue... Read More
A Promise Made…A Promise Kept: Federal Court of Appeal rejects claims that the Celecoxib patent lacks utility
On October 30, 2014, Justice Noël of the Federal Court of Appeal, released the Reasons for Judgment in Apotex Inc. v. Pfizer... Read More
Apotex barred from raising validity issues during assessment of damages
On September 16, 2014 Prothonotary Lafrenière dismissed Apotex’s motion for leave to file an amended Responding Statement of Issues. Apotex sought to... Read More
Forgetting Someone? Court of Appeal orders Hospira to add Sanofi to oxaliplatin judicial review
On September 9, 2014, Justice Gauthier of the Federal Court of Appeal, released the Reasons for Judgment in Hospira Healthcare Corporation v.... Read More
Cancel the Date: Federal Court Vacates Novel Bifurcation for Section 8 Start Date
On September 15, 2014 Prothonotary Aalto granted Pfizer’s motion to amend its pleadings and in doing so vacated a bifurcation order that... Read More
Court denies self-represented litigant leave to adduce new evidence of trade-mark use on appeal
Medos Services Corporation, its principal Alexander Vlasseros, and a related corporation, Marathon Medical Inc., appealed the judgment of the Federal Court that... Read More